I don’t know if I should break up with my boyfriend. I love him, but it feels like everyday we argue over the smallest things and it always feels like it’s gonna end, it never does but I feel like we just compromise to get over it and not really talk about it. He also talks to a lot of girls that he says are just friends but he once had a thing with before us, and I can’t help but be scared and I tell him this.
Also, I really need someone who would be willing to at least look into my church but he said he won’t convert and that’s kind of a loss for me.
I also have this weird feeling that if we stay together he’d be my last person I’ll be with, and I just feel like I need a get more dating out of my system sorta. I don’t know what to do. We’ve been together for almost a year which I know, sounds kinda stupid but it’s been bothering me.
LemonVibe 
It’s not stupid. You need someone your religion. You are not ready for a full time relationship and you don’t trust him (which is really your fears and not something he’s doing so don’t make it seem to him like he is.) Just sit down with him and let him know it’s not him, but you. You are about him, but don’t feel the love and wish him the best in the future. There is no good time to do it. It’s always some holiday, anniversary of something, going through something tough and so on, so go ahead and get it over with so you can both heal and find the person you need.